Johnny Meah is the end of the line—the last carnival sideshow banner painter. His story is a kind of parable for many other jobs. His industry, which is also a rich artistic tradition, is vanishing underneath him. Like many graphic artists with talent and expertise, he is being displaced by radical shifts in technology and the media/entertainment business.
You can spot the last vestiges of Meah’s work a few miles from Manhattan, in the summer when the carnival comes to New Jersey's Meadowlands fairgrounds. The barker (yes, they still exist, as President Obama learned recently) touts human oddities and wonders in front of a range of Meah’s painted banners at “Worlds of Wonder.” There’s the man who, as the banner seems to suggest, hammers nails into his head and the woman who hangs by her hair. But more often Meah’s work is appreciated at the American Folk Art Museum or galleries like Carl Hammer Gallery in Chicago.
What catches the eye of the visual artist in Meah’s painting and other carnival banners is its employment of bold colors, forced perspective and shadowed lettering. There is a complex language of conventionalized stage curtains in the banners, along with framing and accenting starbursts. The visual rhetoric of the banners corresponds to the verbal rhetoric of the sideshow pitchman, with his appeal to customers.
In his book Geeks, Freaks and Wild Girls, Meah discusses his years with the sideshow. I interviewed him recently, and he explained some of the rules and customs of the art to me. He was drawn to painting banners by the challenge of ringing changes on stock situations. He takes conventions and clichés and gives them new twists, like a singer reinterpreting and reviving pop standards.
But beneath the artistic appeal of banners today lies their original function: The sideshow is a business, and banners are its sales reps.
The unavoidable truth is that Meah’s art was employed in the service of an illusion—a gaffe, as the carnival folk call it. It was, in short, a scam—a business that persuaded people to pay money to view humans with misfit limbs or to stare at biological specimens preserved by chemicals or drying.
The banners converted dreary realities into fantasies. They were a form of theater—curtains framing the barker in his box, the ticket taker and the entrance to the tent.
Practical concerns lent the banners some of the features we now see as artistic. For instance, the sideshow banners most prized by collectors, Meah says, are bordered in orange. That, he explains, is because steel grommets or rings for the ropes used to hold up the banners often rust: the orange camouflaged the rust.
Another convention is the so-called “Alive!” bullet, the circle or starburst that looks like the ones on product packages bragging “New and Improved.” “There was a period when there were many ‘stiff shows,’ as we called them,” explains Meah. “That is, shows with fetuses in alcohol or oddities in formaldehyde. The public got burned out on being duped. So the bullet with ‘Alive’ was added.”
But there are tricky claims in the language of posters. “Oddities Past and Present” is legalistic language that allows the banners to depict items that have been shown in the carnival before but might not be any longer (just in case somebody complains).
Meah is part of a tradition that goes back to the 19th century. His predecessors are artists like Snap Wyatt and Fred Johnson whose signed work is visible in WPA and FSA photos of the 1930s. The same confidently painted S-curve serves in many Snap Wyatt banners as shorthand for the curtains other painters render more elaborately. You can often recognize a Snap Wyatt banner, too, by its blue letters shadowed in green.
The carnival world is a parody or cartoon of the commercial world: it is all hype, selling at its extreme. The Alligator Boy is a man with a skin condition, the Penguin boy an old man with unfortunate flipper like arms.
One enduring view backstage was created in 1981 when the late humorist, performer and author Spalding Gray visited a carnival with photographer Randal Levenson. Together, they produced a rare record of the performers out of costume in photographs and words. Their book, In Search of the Monkey Girl, shows the real character behind the performer Popeye, for instance. (The book is now rare; for images see www.randallevenson.com/monkeygirl.html.)
Johnny Meah was born in 1937 in Bristol, Connecticut, where his father was a newspaper cartoonist. He likes to say he grew up in a black-and-white household, dominated by the pen-and-ink drawing of his father’s. Meah took up drawing early in childhood, but the wider world of color appealed to him: bright railroad cars, colorful circus wagons. At 14 he visited his first carnival. He soon met a man called “The Human Cannonball,” Hugo Zachinni, who was then working for the King Brothers Circus. Zachinni was also a renowned painter of sideshow banners when he wasn’t flying out of a cannon for audiences. After his first circus season, Meah was hooked.
From sketching carnival goers to performing, Meah gradually became part of the carnival life. He began working as a clown; later he learned fire eating and sword swallowing. He went to Rhode Island School of Design for a year, but came back. In 1956 he worked a carnival tour with the Ross Manning Company, whose sideshow was run by Leola—also known as “Leo/Leola, Half Man Half Woman,” or Homer Tracy, a female impersonator. As Meah tells it, Leola hired him first to touch up older banners, then sketch new ones. His career was launched.
He was drawn to the mother vein of banner painting that came out of Coney Island. He read about Danny Cassela in an article in the New York Herald Tribune, headlined, “He Glamorizes the Freaks at Coney.” Cassela came from the tradition of Millard and Bulsterbaum, the original firm of local banner painters, handling not just Coney Island shows and traveling carnivals but Nathan’s Famous hot dog signage.
There was work for youngsters like Meah because the banners wore out quickly with the constant movement of the carnival. They were never considered art or even craft in themselves. Banners were regarded as disposable, Meah says. “It was like the old advertisements for potato chips: ‘eat ’em up, we’ll make more.” They were treated roughly, frequently discarded, used as impromptu tarps and replaced. But then the talent of the carnival performers was handled roughly, too.
In 1980 the Smithsonian mounted a show of carnival banners, and Life magazine did a story on them. This caught the eye of the Chicago dealer Carl Hammer, whose gallery also specialized in outsider artist, tattoo “flash” or designs, and other non-mainstream artists. A few years later, he contacted Meah and visited him in Florida.
Meah took Hammer around town of Gibsonton, where carnival people at the time retired. “It was sort of depressing,” Hammer says, “seeing all these sad side show performers in their little houses.” The banners were still thought of as disposables. Meah recalls, “When Carl came down here we had just burned about 50 old banners. When I told him, I thought he would have a heart attack.”
But Hammer found that few buyers shared his enthusiasm for the banners. He began to present them as folk art, like weather vanes, tavern signs or game boards, items popular among folk art collectors. Hammer also sold tattoo flash and the work of outsider artists.
Meah was amazed, he says, when Hammer marketed the banners as folk or outsider art. At first, he resented that. It suggested some guy scrawling on a shovel in Arkansas. Today he accepts what Hammer was doing. “Before Carl, nobody was collecting them so I came to terms with it,” says Meah.
But the problem with the “folk” label, of course, is that it risks obscuring the differences among individual artists or craftspeople. Banner painters differ greatly to one who knows the field. Meah says he admires two very different predecessors: Snap Wyatt and Fred Johnson.
Fred Johnson had no background of actual sideshows, Meah says. “He worked in a big loft in Chicago. He had his own vision of it all. It was like The World According to Garp—he painted the world according to Fred Johnson.”
Meah admired the way Johnson expanded on the stock situations. “For instance,” Meah says, “one perennial (act) is a woman in the electric chair. She gives the illusion that electricity is passing through her body. It radiates from her fingertips and toes. Usually the premise was some fanciful tale that she been hit by lightning or whatever. It’s done with a Tesla coil to surround a woman’s body with electricity, implying she can somehow endure it, or that she is sitting in an electric chair like a doomed criminal.
“Johnson probably painted 50 those of those. In one he showed the woman smiling, sitting in the electric chair in a penal institution somewhere, with stone walls. Over in the corner would be the executioner dressed, for some reason, in a fancy uniform with epaulets and braids. He looked like the doorman at the Ritz Carlton. And Fred Johnson, god bless him, would put in curtains and jungle scenery or French curtains. What the hell are the flowers doing there?”
He also became influenced by a very different sort of painter: Boris Vallejo, the king of the paperback dramatic cover painting. Meah admired the way Vallejo rang changes on clichés and conventions.
Probably the primary factor killing off the sideshow is sensitivity about the exploitation of people inside the tents. Some of the exhibits inside the tents of the sideshow were odd samples in jars, others were people with odd features. Gawking at the malformed and misshapen is downright primitive. But Meah argues that we have to see the history of the sideshow in the context of its time. “Many of these were so-called ‘attic children’ in those days. Families hid them away because they were ashamed. The usual scenario was that when the circus came to town, they met other people and peculiarities and found kinship and support. For the first time, they were part of a community of other people like them.
Now, Meah has written a book about the carnival, completed a novel and is working on another book. He has a website and even a downloadable font. He served as consultant for Carnivale, the short-lived HBO series about a supernaturally charged traveling carnival from the Depression. In fact, he seems to have followed all the advice consultants give people whose industries have vanished: build on your strengths, adapt to the new era.
“A lot of people in our computerized era don’t know that there are real people who actually do this stuff,” he says of banner painting. But for how much longer?
Who today profits from the creative works of the WPA era? Cushing calls for putting the “public” back in this public art.
Section: Inspiration -
Are images more powerful and widely understood than words? Patton looks at the pictorial languages of Otto Neurath and Charles Bliss.
Section: Inspiration -
information design, graphic design, history, Voice
The changing (type) face of New York has been well documented by Paul Shaw. Here, our intrepid guide takes AIGA readers on a tour of Brooklyn.
Section: Inspiration -
typography, signage, Voice
From the Mayflower to the Minnow, we know boats by their names, but what about their logos? Churchman navigates the uncharted waters of boats as brands.
As fellow professionals, we want you to know that we welcome and encourage our membership to be involved with how AIGA Baltimore is run just as much as any board member. As with many professional groups, we are regulated by our chapter bylaws, a formal document that dictates how we govern ourselves. It is a common practice for non-profits to revise their bylaws to be able to reflect the changing landscape and realities of our expanding and dynamic organization. Review our chapter's updated bylaws.
Design Assign is a collaborative partnership that gives back to the greater Des Moines area community through design. Alongside AIGA Iowa, area creatives will use their talents to provide local non-profit organizations with communications products that
can help raise awareness and funds.
Section: Events and Competitions
Are #logos becoming a thing of the past? See the new alternative: https://t.co/LOykwuYaeR @twopointsnet https://t.co/WGKEFlh9mu
44 minutes ago
Get drunk (on kickass #packaging) w/ @MiddayStudio + more designs for #NationalWineDay https://t.co/NOMYyF51XI https://t.co/1N6pQ82Mrr
An hour ago
Don't love what you do? Hear how one designer went from agency to non-profit https://t.co/LT3LleXH1D @AIGAOC https://t.co/aOPsWTvfXO
1 hours ago
5 Questions with Orange Element
May 23, 2016
Revised AIGA Baltimore Chapter Bylaws: For Your Vote
May 22, 2016