From AIGA Insight ~ Topics: AIGA, Corporate Leadership, Fellow, Medal
Why celebrate design during a recession?
Editor’s note: The 2009 AIGA Design Legends Gala took place on Thursday, September 17, at The Waldorf-Astoria in New York City, and honored the 2009 recipients of the AIGA Medal, the AIGA Corporate Leadership Award, the AIGA Fellow Award and the Worldstudio AIGA Scholarships. At the event, AIGA President Debbie Millman reinforced the importance of the design profession’s continuing recognition of great design and designers, and placed both the event and design’s role in the context of challenging economic times. Below are Millman’s remarks reprinted in full.
AIGA president Debbie Millman addresses the audience at the Design Legends Gala (photo: George Delgado).
Several years ago, when working on a book about how designers think, I was challenged by an enormously talented designer who confided that he felt designers talk to ourselves and about ourselves way too much. He pointed out how we have conferences where we talk to ourselves, we give each other awards, we publish each other’s work and words, and basically, we pat each other on the back. I was reminded of these statements early this morning when the man who did this fabulous up-do seemed surprised when I told him that I was attending a gala at the Waldorf-Astoria. “Wow, he said, are people still having those? In this economy?”
It was a good question. We committed to this Gala way before the recession officially began, and had no idea that a financial tsunami would hit the world so hard. Even at last year’s Gala, we had no way of predicting that in one year’s time we would be in midst of the longest post-Depression economic decline ever. The current recession wasn’t actually designated as such until December 2008, but because at that point it was determined to have started in December 2007, in 13 days we are about to enter the 22nd month of what is now being referred to as “The Great Recession.”
Not to be too much of a buzz-kill, but the current recession is also more widespread than any other since the Depression. The Federal Reserve has declared that 86 percent of all industries have cut back production since last November—the most widespread reduction in the 42 years since the Fed has tracked the figure. And every state in the union has reported an increase in unemployment, the first time this has happened in the 32 years that records for unemployment have been kept.
So in the midst of this… do we really need to celebrate design and designers? And ask you to pay for it?
I think the question is especially relevant given that the 18-month freefall in household wealth has been larger since any on record since World War II. Household net worth has fallen a record 11 trillion dollars since the start of the recession. And, according to most economists, it’s unclear when the economy will really recover. Though our Gross Domestic Product seems to have stopped declining, economists universally agree that this isn’t a great indicator of a recovery.
So I ask once again, in the midst of the greatest recession of our time: Do we really need to celebrate design and designers?
My answer to this question is unequivocally, unmistakably loud and proud: yes. Now more than ever. More than any other discipline, designers are in the unique position of being able to impact our culture in significant and profound ways. Designers are creators and innovators; we find solutions where none previously existed. We imagine ideas and opportunities, and we realize those ideas and opportunities! We are currently living in a time where every gesture we make is cinematic and becomes swept up in a swift sequence of gestures that precede and follow it. We cannot waste this opportunity and we cannot shirk away from our responsibility to it.
If you were to look back at the last three great recessions, an interesting pattern emerges. It seems some of our greatest inventions and innovations have been created during these bleak times.
In the Great Recession of the 1870s, an American designer and inventor named Cyrus McCormick created a device to more efficiently cut and harvest crops. A hundred years later, the Academy of Sciences determined that McCormick’s “designs and inventions accomplished more for the cause of agriculture than any other living man.”
At the very same time, Andrew Carnegie founded the Carnegie Steel Company. By the 1890s, the company was the largest and most profitable industrial enterprise in the world. In 1901, the company was renamed U.S. Steel and it is still, to this day, the largest domestically owned steel producer in the United States.
History is peppered with these recession-era innovations: Southwest Airlines was founded in the recession of the 1970s; Costco was founded in the recession of the 1980s; and Apple first introduced the iPod on October 23, 2001, a little over a month after 9/11.
So I say yes—yes—we must continue to celebrate, and we must honor the design innovators of our time. We must celebrate their accomplishments, and we must constantly, steadfastly and ardently recognize their impact and their contributions. The condition of design has become the condition of our culture, and ultimately, brilliant designers such as Carin Goldberg, Doyald Young and Pablo Ferro—and progressive organizations like JetBlue and Patagonia—have the ability to make the world a better place for everyone. No matter how bleak the situation into which we have been thrown by the global economy—it does offer opportunities. Designers need only invent them. By understanding our living and working context, we blow open avenues of opportunity and innovation not yet charted or explored.
Welcome to the sixth annual AIGA Design Legends Gala. Thank you for coming tonight, thank you for helping us honor the great practitioners of our time, and thank you for your continued support of AIGA.
-
While I think it's a stretch to compare the current recession to hardships of the past, I've always found interest in this somewhat inaccurate quote from "The Third Man"
"In Italy for 30 years under the Borgias they had warfare, terror, murder, and bloodshed, but they produced Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, and the Renaissance. In Switzerland they had brotherly love - they had 500 years of democracy and peace, and what did that produce? The cuckoo clock."
Also, I agree on the original idea that many designers out there are all too willing to pat each other on the backs. -
An inappropriate comment was removed. Please add comments judiciously, and refrain from maligning any individual, institution or body of work.
-
I agree that we still need to celebrate design
and disigners even in the midst of the great recession of our time .The needs of the people are keep on changing,they keep on looking for a new things, new design, and new inventions. We must bear in our mind that people have no satisfacation for everything in this world. They always have needs. So to satisfied the needs of the people in each moment of their lives, the design and designers are only things they needed to make them happy and satisfied. -
Yes we should keep celebrating and cultivating great design but perhaps on a less expensive scale. Why do we need to get our hair done and buy expensive outfits to give props to great design? Why not have a huge virtual gala that many more designers and design enthusiasts can attend and participate in instead of making it such and elite and exclusive event. Spread the design love don't hide it in NYC.
-
you shouldn't remove comments that are not inappropriate. you're very biased by removing comments that you don't agree with. shame on you
-
Tracey--the comment we removed was an ad for and a link to a replica handbag site, not something that we disagreed with in regard to the post.
But we don't like replica handbags either, to be clear. -
Design and designers most certainly should be celebrated—independent of economic climate. Good design is transparent, so in the big picture, one just sees the end result—often aloof to the people and process that are imbued into it. So a little acknowledgment from the design community is a good thing.
-
No Debbie - it was a comment stating we shouldn't celebrate design during a recession. have nio clue what you're talking about re: a hangbag site. you removed my original comment.
-
I don't think the recession factor comes into it. Regardless of whichever field people have talent in (sport/arts/literature etc), if they're good (or the best) at what they do then this should be highlighted and commended.
The only field which shouldn't be celebrated in this particular circumstance is banking. -
I removed a comment by "tracey R" not because it expressed an opposing point of view, but because it was malicious, with nothing constructive to add to this discussion. The floor is open to all points of view so long as they do not malign any individual, institution or body of work. In other words, play nice and play fair.
Feel free to email me offlist (by clicking on my name at left). Thanks in advance for keeping this discussion on track and respectful.
Your friendly moderator,
Sue -
let us not confuse need with want. we are mostly about the business of desire fulfillment and creating the illusion that want equals need. The ipod, while changing the landscape of technology, can hardly be said to have made the world a better place. US Steel can be attributed to lending a hand to transforming the city into a mass of cheap, grey real estate to be exploited by the 'haves'. And Costco? More of what you don't need, right now, in bulk. we are manufacturing desire and 'leveling the playing field' by making good little consumers of the entire global village. that expressed, should we applaud our designers? If they are lending a voice to the have-nots, solving real over imagined problems, then yes, let us hold court for them. If, however, we are having galas to have galas, to toast champagne and rub elbows with more of the haves, then nay. nay. nay.
-
"is also more widespread than any other since the Depression" - not just in terms of industries though. There are also more countries affected than the Great Depression simply because we're moved much closer to a single world economy, making everyone much more intertwined. Good when everyone's doing well, not so good when things are bad!
I agree that we must continue to celebrate good work. It is the hope that this bring that will bring confidence back into the economy. -
There is more than one side to the economics of holding a gala. It actually serves to provide or at least maintain jobs for the people that worked to make the gala be successful. When people are struggling with the depressed lifestyle that a recession causes sometimes a little celebration of what is good in the world help add a positiveness in times with little positive to celebrate. Not to say that we should go about with blinders on to the issues that the recession is causing world wide. Hopefully galas provide a forum for discussion of issues and solutions to problems the recession has caused or contributed to. They also provide an opportunity to promote design programs that are making a difference. I agree that some of our greatest achievements as a people have come as a response to necessity and hardship. We don't need to be as elaborate in our celebrations when we, as designers, might use the challenges of the recession as a spring board to solving the problem of how to celebrate in an economically responsible manner. I really liked the idea of using the internet as a tool to include more people world wide in the celebration of design.
-
This article was very interesting.I definitely agree with Kathleen when shes says: "I agree that some of our greatest achievements as a people have come as a response to necessity and hardship." I do believe that the pressure during bad times, helps achieve many needs or wants (for that matter), to better lives, or at least entertain them. I think sometimes people that are not in the design field, do not give enough credit to graphic designers. I think if everyone were more knowledgeable about this topic, maybe there would be more appreciation for what designers do, and what they have accomplished already.
-
I agree with the author and others who have posted that design must be celebrated, even in hard economic times. Design is what is exciting about our world, and designers are the ones who create that. We are the ones who have the power to make things seem more appealing, exciting, etc., which I feel in the long run will help when it comes to this depression which we are in. Even if the ipod didn't make the world a better place, it is still one of the main mp3 players in the world, and will continue to be. This also means that the factories and people making them are probably still doing fairly well, especially when compared to things such as the auto industry, which we all know is falling harder than ever at the moment even despite efforts to save it. I think that if there were enough designers working in the auto industry that concentrated on a couple of good designs for cars, like apple concentrates on a couple of good designs for ipods, consumers wouldn't need or want to buy foreign cars as much as they do. I think that one good, efficient idea of a car design/ways to make that specific car could help some parts of the economy a lot. This also goes for the many other designs and products that in the long run, will lift everyones spirits, hopefully provide some jobs, and help the economy. A lot of times it might be want over need which propels the force behind buying or creating something, but if what everyone WANTS is also something everyone NEEDS and just happens to be created by a designer, then shouldn't we be applauded?
-
Design is creativity which should be celebrated all the time.
-
It is absurd to compare what professional designer are experiencing in the last few years to past recessions. It is a completely different world out there.
Long time ago, Graphic design use to be an art form. Unfortunately it became commodity.
I have been a designer for 35 years. I was respected and well compensated. I study all element of graphic design for four years in an art school while the new wave of “designers” are learning computer programs and Voala, they are officially graphic designer, killing the market with ridiculous design rates. Every shmendrik is a designer now days. Not only that, but hiring companies expect us, creative people, to also become web programers... and they have the audacity to offer close-to-starvation wages.
That's not the way to make a living anymore. -
"Eu sou do Brasil e sei as dificuldades da profissão. O design é fator importante para adecisão de escolha das pessoas. Lamento muito que em meu país design ainda seja artigo de luxo."
I'm from Brazil and I know the difficulties of the profession. The design is an important factor The decision to choose the people. I am sorry that in my country is still design review for a few. But do not give up fighting! -
Good design and innovation will always be in demand.
Simon
bestbusinessangels.com -
I love to design, but I also want to live a life with income. I went to a good school, worked hard, and got nothing. I won a few awards, shook Gary Baseman's hand, smiled and this is what happened: FAIL. My best memory: an interviewer laughed in my face at a design job for the NBA because my work was excellent but I had little experience. I never applied for the job, they found me, as my portfolio became blasted on online websites. How would you feel? I just graduated school and only had a few jobs so far. To think, the strong survive and the weak perish. I suppose I am the weak. That is just one story about landing a design job out of school. I could write a book.
-
There are points here I agree with and don’t agree with. I will agree design should be admired and appreciated. Not only is their work original and creative, but it is also inspiring and admirable. This is something to be very proud of. Not everybody can just sign up for design and expect to be good at it. This is why the best of the best deserve to be acknowledged. In a way, design can be a catalyst for our society and give them confidence that there will be light at the end of the tunnel.
The part of this that I don’t agree with is where design has the possibility to end the recession. The author makes valid points about Southwest Airlines, Costco, and Apple, but those three things didn’t end the economical downturn of their time. The economy needs a lot more to happen than a design, advertisement, or PR stunt. People first need to start buying more stock, homes, vehicles, real estate and so on. That’s obviously tough to do given unemployment is still slightly over 10% in this country and people are still saving what money they do earn. That’s where I find it hard to believe a design would be a cure-all for the economic downturn. It would be really nice if that were the case, however. -
Great design should always be celebrated. There will always be a need to highlight how good design can be and how it can make a difference.
That difference may not only be in dollar terms but it can also be lifesaving. The IDEO guys who designed a better defibulator are now saving lives because they created amazing simplified design. -
What is the similarity and difference between these associations and what does it mean to you?
American Institute of Graphic Artists
American Institute of Architects
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
National Association of Professional Contractors
American Engineering Association
Professional Photographers of America
This is at the core of all of your comments and questions.

Comments